Frivolous reporting and deletion of similar models on Printables, publishing here instead for now
Mr. Masaki Hirahara, AKA "Mott" reported a couple of my designs on Printables, and they got deleted without the admins even asking about it. Apparently they don't adhere to the law about these things, they just delete if someone asks them to delete and give undue protections to the "original designer". I decided to share them here at least for now. Also attached are the notifications and side by side
images confirming they are different models.
I only looked at pictures, and decided to make something similar. I did not have access to his 3D models or printed objects. So they're not his designs, since that would require patents. With regards to the V-mount sticker base, I had already had a vague idea about it before even seeing Mott's model on his store, since it's a really simple idea. He doesn't share or sell his models, he only sells finished prints, and the prices are insane when including shipping from Japan. And these were simple enough to just quickly design myself.
So, enjoy these models, inspired by his designs, but created by me :)
(I tried to upload the .f3d CAD files too, as single files and in a .zip folder, but this site didn't accept neither. I can upload those too if someone wants them and can say how? I'd rather not use G Drive, Dropbox etc but just upload here.) Print instructions for Wedge carabiner: Bending part is optimized for Bambu's PETG-HF filament, so YMMV on different filaments.
Use 4 or 5 wall loops for strength in the carabiner area
Printables admins responded with: "Hi,
We understand your statement regarding the design process and the fact that you modeled these files yourself. However, the designs were copied very closely from the original work, and we have accepted the report as a violation of the original author’s design rights.
Even if a model is recreated from scratch, closely mimicking the aesthetic and functional design of another creator's unique work without authorization still falls under our infringement policy.
If you wish to discuss this further or seek permission to share similar designs, we recommend contacting the original designer directly. You can reach them via their Instagram profile: https://www.instagram.com/mott_jp/
I hope you can understand. In case of changes or find the better solution we are in contact.
Best regards, The Printables Team" And
"Hi, thank you for your message. I will definitely follow this case, and I am committed to finding a fair solution for both sides as we move forward. We appreciate your models and all the effort you put into creating them. We are never happy about having to remove content from Printables, but we must respect the original designs of other creators. Thank you for your understanding. Sincerely, M"
Neither of which make any sense, but it is what it is. I also sent a message to Mott on Instagram 5 days ago and an email 3 days ago with no response.